Temporary Injunctions in Civil Suits: Legal Criteria, Case Laws & CPC Provisions Explained : When and How Courts Grant Temporary Injunctions: Order 39 & Section 151 CPC Overview: Temporary vs. Mandatory Injunction: Legal Tests and Judicial Approach under Civil Procedure Code:Ex-Parte and Interim Injunctions: Essentials, Exceptions & Case Law Insights: Understanding Temporary Injunctions under CPC: Prima Facie Case, Irreparable Harm & Balance of Convenience

 Grant of Temporary Injunction under CPC: Principles, Procedure, and Judicial Discretion What is the criteria to grant temporary injunction by a civil court? On what basis temporary injunction is issued in a suit? Can an injunction be issued  without giving notice of application to the opposite party?  What are the essential ingredients for granting a temporary injunction?  Discuss relevant principles that govern grant of temporary injunction. Whether a  temporary injunction can be granted in the form of mandatory injunction?  What are the principles and considerations for exercising discretion to issue temporary  injunctions during the pendency of a suit. Can such an injunction be issued only under Order 39, read with section 94 C.P.C. or also in exercise of inherent powers saved by section 151 C.P. C

CRITERIA AND PRINCIPLES FOR GRANT OF TEMPORARY INJUNCTION BY CIVIL COURT

Temporary Injunction is a judicial remedy issued during the pendency of a suit to prevent threatened or continuing breach of the plaintiff’s rights and to preserve the subject matter of the suit. The Civil Procedure Code, 1908 (CPC) primarily deals with it under:

• Order 39 Rules 1 & 2

• Section 94(c) & (e)

• Section 151 (inherent powers)

---

🔶 ESSENTIAL INGREDIENTS FOR GRANT OF TEMPORARY INJUNCTION

The court must be satisfied on the following three-fold test, also known as the "triple test" laid down in Dalpat Kumar v. Prahlad Singh, AIR 1993 SC 276:

1. Prima Facie Case

   • The plaintiff must show a substantial question to be investigated and that his case has a probability of success.

2. Irreparable Injury

   • If the injunction is not granted, the plaintiff would suffer injury that could not be compensated adequately by damages.

3. Balance of Convenience

   • The court must weigh the comparative mischief or inconvenience likely to be caused to the parties and grant injunction if it favors the plaintiff.

---

🔶 CAN INJUNCTION BE ISSUED WITHOUT NOTICE TO THE OPPOSITE PARTY?

Yes, ex-parte temporary injunction can be granted without notice, under Rule 3 of Order 39, if delay in granting the injunction would defeat the purpose of the injunction.

However, the court must:

• Record reasons for granting such order.

• Require the applicant to deliver a copy of the application and supporting documents to the opposite party immediately.

Case law: Morgan Stanley Mutual Fund v. Kartick Das, (1994) 4 SCC 225
Ex-parte injunctions must be granted with caution, and reasons must be recorded to justify urgency.

---

🔶 WHETHER TEMPORARY INJUNCTION CAN BE IN FORM OF MANDATORY INJUNCTION?

Generally, temporary injunctions are prohibitory in nature, restraining a party from doing a certain act.
But in rare and exceptional cases, mandatory injunction (i.e., compelling a party to do an act) can be granted as an interim relief when:

• The case is exceptionally strong, and

• Compelling circumstances exist to prevent injustice.

Case Law: Dorab Cawasji Warden v. Coomi Sorab Warden, (1990) 2 SCC 117
Interim mandatory injunction may be granted to preserve or restore status quo ante.

---

🔶 DISCRETIONARY NATURE OF RELIEF

The grant of temporary injunction is discretionary and equitable in nature, to be exercised judiciously and not arbitrarily.

Case Law: Gujarat Bottling Co. Ltd. v. Coca Cola Co., (1995) 5 SCC 545
Discretion must be exercised on sound legal principles and not whimsically.

---

🔶 WHETHER INJUNCTION CAN BE GRANTED UNDER SECTION 151 CPC?

Yes, even if the case does not strictly fall under Order 39 Rules 1 & 2, the court can grant injunction under its inherent powers under Section 151 CPC to prevent abuse of process of the court and to meet the ends of justice.

Case Law: Manohar Lal Chopra v. Rai Bahadur Rao Raja Seth Hiralal, AIR 1962 SC 527
Held that injunction can be granted under Section 151 CPC where Order 39 is not applicable, but the situation demands equitable relief.

---

🔶 LEGAL FRAMEWORK:

Provision	Purpose
Order 39 Rule 1 CPC	Cases where injunction can be granted
Order 39 Rule 2 CPC	Restraining breach of contract/other obligations
Order 39 Rule 3 CPC	Procedure for ex parte injunction
Section 94 CPC	Supplemental proceedings (e.g., granting injunction)
Section 151 CPC	Inherent powers to meet ends of justice

✅ CONCLUSION:

Temporary injunction is granted based on judicial principles and equitable discretion. Courts consider urgency, rights involved, and the balance of harm. Though primarily governed by Order 39 CPC, it can also be invoked under Section 151 CPC in suitable cases. Mandatory injunctions can be granted temporarily but only in exceptional and compelling circumstances.