A simplified explanation of the concept of Res Judicata under Section 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC)

 A simplified explanation of the concept of Res Judicata under Section 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC):

---

Res Judicata (Section 11 CPC) – Simplified Explanation

Meaning:

"Res Judicata" is a Latin term that means “a matter already judged.”

It means that once a court has decided a matter fairly and finally between the same parties, it cannot be re-opened or re-decided in any other suit.

---

Section 11 CPC – The Rule:

No court shall try any suit or issue which has already been directly and substantially in issue, in a former suit, between the same parties, and has been finally decided by a competent court.

---

Conditions for Res Judicata to Apply:

1. Same parties (or their legal representatives)

2. Same issue in both suits

3. Direct and substantial issue (not minor or incidental)

4. Earlier decision by a competent court

5. Final judgment in the earlier suit

6. Same title, same cause of action

---

Example (Simple):

In Case A, Ramesh sues Suresh over ownership of a piece of land and loses.

Now, Ramesh cannot file Case B again against Suresh for the same land and the same claim.
This is barred by Res Judicata.

---

Purpose of Res Judicata:

• Prevent multiple litigations

• Avoid conflicting decisions

• Save judicial time and cost

• Ensure finality of judgments

---

Important Notes:

• Even an erroneous decision can operate as Res Judicata if not appealed.

• It applies to civil suits, writs, and appeals.

• Public interest litigation (PIL) may have exceptions.

• It applies to issues of fact and law if already decided.

---